Grace Is Not Avoidance

Scripture

Receive

Begin by remembering that grace is not God’s decision to stop caring about what we do. Grace is God’s movement toward us in Jesus Christ, a movement powerful enough to expose what is false and create a different future.

In Jesus Christ, God has come near. In Jesus Christ, we are forgiven. Grace has already arrived, and grace will not leave us unchanged.

Notice

When people fear that grace will weaken accountability, they are often protecting something important. Harm should be named. People who have been injured should not be asked to pretend that everything is fine. A community should not use forgiveness to rush past consequences, preserve an institution’s reputation or restore an unsafe relationship.

Yet fear and condemnation do not reliably produce honest responsibility. They can produce concealment, counterattack, performance or despair. Grace offers another possibility: because our worth does not depend upon proving our innocence, we may become able to acknowledge what we have done.

Listen

Read Luke 19:1–10. Notice the sequence. Zacchaeus wants to see Jesus, but Jesus sees him, calls him by name and chooses to stay at his house. The crowd objects. Then Zacchaeus speaks about giving to the poor and repaying fourfold where he has defrauded anyone.

Interpreters disagree about the precise force of Zacchaeus’s words. The Greek verbs translated “I give” and “I repay” are present-tense forms. They may describe an existing practice, announce a new resolve or carry some combination of defense and transformation. The passage should not be made to prove more than it does.

The sequence is nevertheless clear: Jesus’ seeing, calling and table fellowship are not rewards for a restitution plan already presented to him. Jesus moves toward Zacchaeus before Zacchaeus’s public declaration. The encounter bears economic and relational fruit, whether the words describe a newly promised practice or bring an existing practice into the light.

Distinguish what grace holds together

Forgiveness, accountability, repair, reconciliation and trust are related, but they are not interchangeable.

Forgiveness names release from the debt of vengeance and, in Christian proclamation, God’s gracious refusal to let sin have the final word. Accountability means truthfully answering for conduct and accepting appropriate consequences. Repair is the concrete work of addressing damage where repair is possible. Reconciliation is the restoration of relationship, which requires truth, freedom and sufficient safety from all involved. Trust grows through trustworthy action over time; it cannot be commanded as proof that forgiveness has occurred.

Grace can begin before all of these processes are complete. That does not make the processes unnecessary. It makes them possible without requiring anyone to save themselves through them.

Wrestle

Consider two distortions.

Grace without truth says, “You are forgiven, so we do not need to discuss what happened.” It protects the person or system that caused harm and leaves the wounded to carry the cost.

Truth without grace says, “What you did is the only truth about you, and nothing can change.” It can name wrongdoing accurately while leaving no room for repentance, repair or new life.

The gospel refuses both distortions. It tells the truth about sin while locating every person and every community within the prior, active and transforming mercy of God.

You might consider:

• When have you seen forgiveness used to avoid accountability?
• What is lost when a person is permanently reduced to the worst thing they have done?
• What forms of repair can be offered without demanding reconciliation?
• How can a community center the safety and agency of those harmed while still believing that people who cause harm can change?

Practice an honest apology

For this exercise, use a fictional or low-risk situation. Do not begin with abuse, trauma or a conflict that could place someone in danger.

Imagine that you repeatedly interrupted a colleague, dismissed a family member’s concern or failed to complete something you had promised. Practice an apology that includes these movements in ordinary language:

1. Name what you did without making the other person prove it.
2. Acknowledge its likely effect without claiming to know everything they felt.
3. Accept responsibility without adding an excuse.
4. Express remorse.
5. Ask what repair may be possible, while not making the harmed person responsible for designing all of it.
6. Respect the other person’s freedom, boundaries and timing.
7. Change the behavior and accept that trust may return slowly or not at all.

Try saying the apology in one connected paragraph. Notice where you want to explain, minimize, shift attention to your intentions or ask to be reassured. Do not shame that impulse. Let grace make enough room to set it down.

Practice repair

Ask privately whether there is one modest repair you can begin this week. It might be returning something, correcting a public misstatement, paying what you owe, acknowledging someone’s contribution or changing a repeated behavior. Do not contact a person if doing so would violate a boundary or renew harm. Repair must not become another way to demand access.

Carry

Before a difficult act of accountability, repeat:

I do not have to prove that I am innocent in order to remain within God’s mercy. Grace has already arrived. Now I can tell the truth and participate in repair.

A prayer

Jesus, you saw Zacchaeus and called him before the crowd could define him. Meet us with a grace that neither flatters nor abandons us. Give us courage to name harm, accept responsibility, protect those who are vulnerable and undertake repair. Grow in us the fruit of a changed life. Amen.

Sources and further reading

Luke 19:1–10; Heidelberg Catechism, Question 86; Westminster Confession of Faith, 6.081–6.086; Joel B. Green, The Gospel of Luke, 670–672; Patson K. Motuku and Ernest van Eck, “Justice and Reconciliation in Luke 19:1–10,” Verbum et Ecclesia 45, no. 1 (2024).

Open the complete Sources and Further Reading guide.